ST. LOUIS, MO – October 4, 2026 (STL.News) More than a century after Elsa Lemp Wright died from a gunshot wound, questions surrounding her death are receiving renewed attention as a longtime Lemp family researcher revisits one of the darkest chapters in St. Louis history.
Stephen P. Walker, author of Lemp: The Haunting History, discussed Elsa’s 1920 death during an Aug. 25, 2026, appearance on The Brighter Side of Blue Podcast.
The episode examines whether modern standards would interpret the circumstances surrounding Elsa’s death the same way.
The historical account identifies her death as suicide. Walker, however, questions that conclusion.
There is an important distinction: No evidence has been reviewed by STL.News that establishes that Elsa was murdered, and researchers questioning the case, have not produced an official reclassification of her death.
Instead, the renewed debate centers on reported inconsistencies in surviving records and questions about how investigators conducted the original investigation.
Who was Elsa Lemp Wright?
Elsa was the daughter of William J. Lemp Sr., whose family built one of St. Louis’s best-known brewing businesses.
According to the City of St. Louis’ historical records, William Lemp expanded the brewery his father, Adam Lemp, founded. By 1875, William was the largest beer brewer in St. Louis, and the business became the William J. Lemp Brewing Company in 1892.
By the end of the 19th century, the company employed more than 1,000 people.
The family’s wealth, however, eventually became overshadowed by a succession of personal tragedies.
St. Louis County Library historical material identifies four members of the Lemp family who died by suicide involving firearms: William Lemp Sr. in 1904, Elsa in 1920, William J. Lemp Jr. in 1922, and Charles Lemp in 1949.
The same historical account makes an important distinction often lost in retellings of the Lemp story: Elsa was the exception among those four deaths because hers did not occur inside the Lemp Mansion.
Elsa died at 13 Hortense Place
Elsa was married to Thomas H. Wright, a St. Louis businessman.
The couple had divorced before reconciling and remarrying shortly before her death.
On March 20, 1920, Elsa died following a gunshot wound at the couple’s residence at 13 Hortense Place in St. Louis.
Her death became historically recorded as a suicide.
More than a century later, however, researchers continue to examine whether surviving documentation supports that conclusion as conclusively as generations of Lemp histories have suggested.
The Missouri State Archives maintains the state’s historical death-certificate collection covering this period, while St. Louis probate records also contain an entry for Elsa Lemp Wright dated March 24, 1920.
Neither the existence of those records nor later questions about the investigation establish that a homicide occurred.
Researchers found discrepancies in surviving records
Questions surrounding Elsa’s death did not originate with the 2026 podcast.
Filmmakers Franki Cambeletta and Jeremy King began examining the case years earlier while developing a documentary originally known as The Case for Elsa Lemp.
In 2017, St. Louis Magazine reported that their examination of surviving records uncovered what they considered significant irregularities.
One involved the date.
The researchers identified a coroner’s document listing March 19, even though Elsa’s death is otherwise identified as occurring March 20, 1920. They also reported contradictory witness statements and questioned aspects of the examination conducted at the Hortense Place residence.
Another issue concerned a household driver.
According to the magazine’s account of the filmmakers’ research, the driver was reportedly inside the house but was not interviewed during the investigation.
The filmmakers also focused on approximately 40 minutes between the reported shooting and notification of police.
Those details are reasons researchers have questioned the original investigation. They are not proof that Elsa was killed by another person.
Forensic and law-enforcement experts examined the story
The documentary team sought outside opinions while researching the case.
St. Louis Magazine reported that people consulted included medical examiners, a former St. Louis police detective, a crime-scene analyst and a firearms expert.
The researchers also gained access to the interior of 13 Hortense Place while reconstructing the circumstances surrounding Elsa’s death.
Their documentary project has continued developing in the years since.
Now titled Lemp’s Last Wright, the film is scheduled to premiere March 20, 2027 — 107 years after Elsa’s death.
The filmmakers characterize the case more aggressively than the established historical account. The project’s website says its investigation produced findings that, in the filmmakers’ assessment, point toward possible foul play.
That conclusion belongs to the filmmakers.
It should not be confused with an official homicide determination.
Stephen Walker brings the questions back in 2026
The Aug. 25 podcast has now returned the case to public attention.
Walker has studied the Lemp family for decades. The Gateway Arch’s current biography of Walker says his interest began with a 1982 visit to the Lemp Mansion and grew into years of research through libraries, archives, and museums.
His book on the family was published in 1989.
During the 2026 podcast interview, the discussion turns specifically to Elsa’s death, including conflicting accounts, the reported delay before police were contacted, the location of the firearm, and statements attributed to household employees.
The program then puts the central question to retired law-enforcement officers: If investigators encountered the same circumstances today, would they conclude that the death was a suicide?
It is an intriguing historical question.
It is not a finding that Elsa was murdered.
The Lemp family’s documented tragedies
The renewed attention to Elsa’s death comes against the much broader history of tragedy surrounding the Lemp family.
William Lemp Sr. died by suicide in 1904.
Elsa followed in 1920.
William Lemp Jr., who had succeeded his father in the brewing business, died by suicide in 1922.
According to the City of St. Louis, the Lemp brewery had closed operations as a result of Prohibition. Its 18-building, 14-acre complex was sold at auction on June 28, 1922, for $585,000.
William Jr. died six months later.
Charles Lemp died by suicide in 1949.
St. Louis County Library records that all of those suicides except Elsa’s occurred inside the Lemp Mansion.
The concentration of tragedy within one prominent family helped fuel the mansion’s later reputation as one of St. Louis’ best-known supposedly haunted properties.
Stories of paranormal activity remain folklore rather than established historical fact.
Was Elsa Lemp murdered?
Based on the publicly available evidence, that question cannot responsibly be answered with a yes.
The historical account identifies Elsa’s death as suicide.
Modern researchers have identified what they describe as inconsistencies in surviving documentation and weaknesses in the original investigation. Those findings make the circumstances legitimate subjects for historical investigation.
They do not establish homicide.
Nor does questioning the suicide determination establish that Thomas Wright or any other person was responsible for Elsa’s death.
More than a century has passed. Investigative methods in 1920 differed substantially from modern forensic procedures, witnesses are deceased, and surviving documentation may be incomplete.
That makes certainty increasingly difficult.
What is clear is that interest in the case has not disappeared.
Walker has again raised the subject publicly in 2026, while the documentary filmmakers behind Lemp’s Last Wright are preparing to present their investigation in 2027.
For a family already inseparable from St. Louis history and legend, the circumstances surrounding Elsa Lemp Wright’s death remain one of its most disputed chapters.
For now, however, the distinction remains essential:
Elsa Lemp Wright’s death is historically recorded as a suicide. Murder remains a theory advanced by researchers, not an established fact.
STL.News supports The Brighter Side of Blue podcasts.
Read St. Louis Local News at STL.News
