Arizona AG Brnovich Announces Arizona Initiative Law Upheld at State Supreme Court

Arizona AG Brnovich Announces Arizona Initiative Law Upheld at State Supreme Court

(STL.News) – Attorney General Mark Brnovich announced this morning that the Arizona Supreme Court has ruled in his favor and denied relief in a lawsuit that challenged Arizona statutes and constitutional provisions that protect the integrity of the initiative process.

In a 6-1 decision, the Arizona Supreme Court accepted jurisdiction of the case but rejected Plaintiffs’ claims on the merits.

Plaintiffs (four special interest groups proposing initiatives) filed a lawsuit last month directly in the Arizona Supreme Court trying to force the State to accept signatures online through E-Qual, the state’s online signature-gathering platform, because of the COVID-19 health crisis.  Plaintiffs challenged Arizona statutes that precluded electronic signature gathering but ignored a provision of Article IV of the Arizona Constitution, which clearly requires signatures on initiative petitions to be signed in the presence of a circulator.

“My job is to defend the law and I’m going to continue doing so as long as I’m Attorney General,” said AG Brnovich.  “A health crisis is not an excuse to ignore the constitution.”

Additionally, the challengers could have started collecting signatures in November 2018 to qualify for the November 2020 ballot.  This provided the challengers 20 months to obtain the required signatures, but most of the Plaintiffs did not begin circulating petitions until February of this year.

Expanding access to E-Qual for the initiative process is up to Arizona voters or policymakers.  As the Arizona Supreme Court has previously explained, if this provision of the Constitution becomes “too inconvenient for present-day operation, the remedy is to amend it—not to ignore it.”  Western Devcor, Inc. v. City of Scottsdale, 168 Ariz. 426, 432 (1991).


About Marty Smith 10908 Articles
Marty Smith is the Editor in Chief and a founder of STL.News,, and St. Louis Restaurant Review. As Editor in Chief, Smith is responsible for the content posted on the network with the help of the publishing team, which is located around the globe. Additionally, Smith is responsible for building a network of aggregator sites to manage the content involving thousands of sources.